Menu
Русский English

The Good Liar goofs

Anachronisms

Although the film is set in 2009, Roy places the current polymer UK ten-pound note on the counter in the butcher's, rather than the paper note that would have been used at the time.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

While Roy and Betty are at Slough railway station, a train with a partly purple livery hurtles through. This is one of the new Elizabeth line units, which as of late 2019 were still being run on a trial basis and did not exist in 2009, the year in which the film is set. Roy also departs on a train carrying GWR branding; in 2009 such services would have worn a First Great Western livery, since the GWR name had not been reinstated until 2015.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

The contemporary double-decker buses appearing in several of the film's establishing shots of London were not in service in 2009, the year in which the story is set.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

Inside Roy's flat the interior is a single, spacious room featuring a generous bay window with stained-glass detailing, yet from the street the property appears as a modest-sized room with small, flat sash windows. No effort is made to reconcile the interior with the exterior.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

Continuity

The two steaks Roy and Vincent buy from the Russian butcher's do not match the ones later shown in Betty's kitchen — in her kitchen the steaks are cut thicker and appear narrower.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

Factual errors

Spoiler!

The audience is led to believe that "Betty" can be certain of "Roy"'s identity, since she reportedly possesses a lock of Hans' hair from 1943 alongside a sample cut from "Roy" when she trimmed his hair. In reality, DNA cannot typically be retrieved from mere hair clippings — the genetic material is located in the hair root (follicle), which is usually absent from cut strands.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

In 2009 Stephen tells Betty and Roy that he is travelling to Spandau Prison to carry out research. The prison was demolished in 1987 — literally pulverised, with its remains scattered at sea — to prevent neo‑Nazis turning it into a shrine. A shopping centre was later built on the site.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱
Spoiler!

When Roy kills Bryn on the Underground, they are plainly in full view of passengers at the far end of the platform, yet nobody seems to notice the shouting and screaming from their struggle. It's hard to accept that Roy could so easily get away with pushing someone into the path of an oncoming train on the London Underground, especially given the many CCTV cameras in Tube stations. Discarding the coat would do little to hide one's movements entering and leaving the Tube.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

Miscellaneous

The flowers in the painting described as lilies resemble the blooms often called "calla lilies" or "callas". They are not actually members of the lily family, Liliaceae, so they make for a rather curious example of a flower labelled 'lily'...

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱
Spoiler!

Helen Mirren's character claims she has waited 60 years since 1943 to take her revenge on Ian McKellen's character, which places the present day in 2003. However, earlier in the film she reveals she bought a new car — a silver Volkswagen Golf Mark 6 — a model that was introduced in 2008, so it could not have been in her possession at the time in which the film is set.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱

Revealing mistakes

Spoiler!

Most of the more substantial German-speaking parts are plainly played by actors who are not native German speakers.

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱
Spoiler!

As Roy (Ian McKellen) and Betty (Helen Mirren) prepare to enter their passwords to authorise the money transfer, Roy begins to spell the word 'lilies', but inadvertently pronounces it as 'I.L.L.' instead of 'L.I.L.'

🧡
👏
🥺
🤔
🥱
2025, USA, Sci-Fi
2025, Japan, Action, Adventure, Animation
2025, Russia, Adventure, Comedy, Family
2025, USA, Family, Fantasy, Musical
2025, USA, Crime, Thriller
2025, USA, Sci-Fi
2025, Russia, Adventure, Fairy Tale
2025, Belgium / France / USA, Animation
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Read more